Blog Ipsa Loquitur

The New York Criminal Law and Procedure blog tries to answer what is the “interest of justice”? Courts in New York are authorized by the Criminal Procedure Law to disregard certain rules only in the interest of justice, but it’s undefined and (I think) rather vague.

Larry Cunningham took a stab at it in an article about the appeals process. It’s a good read, and you really don’t want to be outside on the East Coast right now, anyway.

Published on under Legal Theory

Yesterday, on Father’s Day, Google automatically added a reminder for users to call their fathers via the Gmail web site. We pick up the resulting scandal from Tech Crunch:

Albeit micro, ‘Reminder: Call dad’ is just one more example of Google not entirely grasping social niceties. It should be obvious that putting up a status message that’s offensive to some users especially users whose fathers have passed away, or were abusive, et al., in a place that most people consider private, might not go over well.  But it wasn’t.

Notwithstanding the bit about folks’ fathers who have just passed away, because that is inarguably sad; I’m going to post a link to Louis C.K.’s sketch about White People Problems and make one smartass comment myself.

The giant international corporation that indexes a startling approximation of the sum total of human knowledge and makes it available for free on a global information network does not entirely grasp social niceties. Everything is ruined forever.

Published on under Irreverently Irrelevant

My friend Huma on her fashion blog that sometimes talks about law stuff:

Crying ‘freedom of speech’ every time anyone has a problem with someone else for hateful or racist or offensive remarks gets us nowhere, unless it’s an actual case of a First Amendment violation (again, by a government actor) because, really? We all know we have a right to say pretty much whatever we want. We even have a right to defame people, really (as long as it doesn’t stray into the narrow scope of hate speech as defined by SCOTUS) – but those we defame have a clear right to sue us for it.

She makes a number of really good points about free speech as it relates to Tracy Morgan’s ill-considered comments about gay people (hint: free speech has nothing to do with it). This is me at pretty much every party where someone brings up Constitutional Law. Except taller and less articulate.

Published on under Legal Theory

From Ars Technica: Bloomberg says Comcast is already violating conditions of NBCU merger:

In Washington DC for example, Comcast carries CNN, Fox News, MSNBC and CNBC on channels 35-39. Bloomberg TV, by contrast, is way down the dial ot channel 103, next to C-Span 2 and C-Span 3.

[…]

When it approved the merger, the FCC noted that “by foreclosing or disadvantaging rival programming networks, Comcast can increase subscribership or advertising revenue for its own programming content.”

I am shocked. Shocked, I say! Who could have foreseen this?

Published on under The News

Jezebel has a cute video highlighting the crimes of Ferris Bueller. Really, I think this just proves that Principal Rooney was the real hero of the film. Damn that kid!

Save Ferris

The video shows Ferris committing:

  • Grand Theft Auto
  • Speeding in a School Zone
  • Littering
  • Speeding
  • Petty Theft
  • Computer Tampering/Fraud
  • Changing Public Records
  • Trespassing on Private Property
  • Reckless Driving
  • Identity Theft
  • Breaking and Entering
  • Inciting a Riot

But many of these aren’t actually crimes in Illinois (where the movie takes place). I’m not certain where some of the names of these crimes come from, but the law nerd in me cannot let this stand. Watch the video before you read on, unless you’ve memorized every second of the movie.

The Crimes

For starters, Grand Theft Auto doesn’t exist in Illinois, but they have a regular old Theft statute. Now, Wikipedia says the Ferrari 250 GT California model was worth $350,000, making this a Class 1 Felony Theft, which is punishable by up to 15 years in prison. Speeding in a School Zone is also not a thing, but the Illinois Vehicle Code does have a section titled “Special Speed Limit While Passing Schools,” the violation of which is punishable by a minimum fine of $150 for a first offense, slightly less than the $250 minimum for speeding in a construction zone.

Littering totally is a crime, though, and is prohibited in the Litter Control Act. It’s also punishable by six months in prison and a $1,500 fine. Speeding is another helpfully vague title; in Illinois, it’s covered in 625 ILCS §5/11-601. If Mr. Bueller was speeding really egregiously, he was guilty of the amusingly titled “Driving 31 Miles Per Hour or More in Excess of the Applicable Limit,” which is pretty much the opposite of vague. D31MPHOMIEOTAL is a Class A Misdemeanor, punishable by up to a year in prison and a $2,500 fine.

Also, Petty Theft isn’t a crime as such, but the regular crime of Theft is a petty offense if the stolen property was lost or waylaid. Petty offenses are not punishable by any jail time, but are punishable by a $1,000 fine and 6 months’ probation.

However, Computer Tampering is a crime in Illinois - it’s 720 ILCS §5/16D-3, and it describes pretty much exactly what Ferris did. In fact, it might even be Aggravated Computer Tampering, if he has disrupted or interfered with vital operations of his local government. Personally, I’d argue that education is the among the most vital operation a government can undertake, but I’d bet that the case law completely disagrees with me. Regardless, Computer Tampering is a Class 4 Felony, punishable by up to 4 years in prison.

The next one, Changing Public Records doesn’t seem to be a crime, at least in Illinois. I think the single most applicable crime to what is described here is Computer Tampering from the previous paragraph; if you wanted to go for a second crime, I’d try Interference with an Institution of Public Education. That one is a Class C Misdemeanor, punishable by up to 30 days in prison and a $1,500 fine. Tresspassing on Private Property **[sic] is properly called Criminal Trespass to Real Property in Illinois, a Class B Misdemeanor, good for 6 months in prison and a $1,500 fine. **Reckless Driving, however, is the correct name for what Ferris is doing. Covered by 625 ILCS §5/11-503, it’s a Class 4 Felony, which carries a maximum jail term of 3 years.

As far as Ferris and Identity Theft go, that one is a bit of a stretch. The law covers a lot of contingencies, and the only one that even arguably covers what Ferris & co. is the following; anyone who

uses any personal identification information … of another for the purpose of gaining access to any record of the actions taken, communications made or received, or other activities or transactions of that person, without the prior express permission of that person

is guilty of the crime of Identity Theft. Personal Identification Information is defined to include a person’s name, so maaaaaybe if Abe Froman’s reservation at the restaurant was an “activity or transaction,” that’s Identity Theft. It’s arguable, but I don’t think it passes the straight face test. (Again, I’m not going to cite case law here, I’m just interested in naming these crimes properly.) It’s a Class 2 Felony, which carries a maximum penalty of 7 years in jail. That makes me think the case law must have a “Sausage King exception” or something; poor Ferris shouldn’t miss prom, college, and grad school just for cutting in line to get some pancreas.

The Weird Crimes

The single most puzzling entry on this list is Breaking and Entering, which is an antiquated term for Burglary. Burglary is, of course, a crime in Illinois, but burglary is trespassing with the intent of committing a crime inside the premises you’re trespassing within. The Jezebel video makes it seem like simply trespassing into someone’s house is Breaking and Entering, but that’s simply not right. We’ve already covered Trespassing above.

The last one, Inciting a Riot, is almost as puzzling. That’s simply not a crime in Illinois. Disrupting a parade and causing a dance number to break out in the middle of the street could be creating a Public Nuisance, which is the criminal obstruction of public streets. Similarly, it might fit the catch-all Disorderly Conduct, which is an unreasonable act that alarms/disturbs another, and provokes a breach of the peace; this is a Class C Misdemeanor, punishable by up to 30 days in prison and a $1,500 fine. A Public Nuisance is a simple petty offense, punishable by a $100 fine.

In Conclusion

This is why we can’t have nice things. Jezebel posted a perfectly fine video, and I went and nerded all over it. But now you know what to expect when you re-enact Ferris’s crime spree across the fine state of Illinois.

Published on under Legal Theory